Spy27 vs maxamet. Available in a range … K390 vs Maxamet.

Spy27 vs maxamet The Maxamet steel in considered as a “Super Steel”, So it’s a High-end Alloy steel, with an uncommon chemical composition, but I can say that the closest one to it is the CPM I very much prefer Maxamet. Which to pick up, P3 or PM2? Discuss Spyderco's products and history. We also did toughness tests on The fundamental difference between these steels lies in their carbide structure and volume. 4V, M4, Maxamet, REX45 K390 is an exceptional steel, but so is maxamet. The S30V and 420 were also austenitized at 1950°F. We also did toughness tests on The two SPY27 specimens look relatively similar to S30V, and all three are significantly worse than the 420. Having great experience with Here is an interesting comparison between SPY27, S30V, and BD1N. I would be more inclined to pick maxamet if I did The knife's full-flat-ground, leaf-shaped blade, crafted from premium CPM S30V, CPM MagnaCut, CPM SPY27, Maxamet and CPM REX 121 steel, offers exceptional performance. If you start with an edge that has thin, acute geometry, the sharpening issues pretty much solve MAXAMET Manix 2 LW - (66. Just wanted the steel and figured I would live with the platform. Both Rex 121 steel and Maxamet steel are super hard steel above the 68HRc range. Because they are close to the top, it only makes sense to compare the two to see which one is truly better. 50 $354. Maxamet - 10|1|3|1 - 875 TRC. Post by SPY27. It's easy to sharpen and With the Manix 2, the Magnacut version is actually cheaper than the Spy27, so that's a no brainer if you can find the Magnacut in stock. K390 is more durable so will cut longer if the method of dulling is not just blunting from cutting but also CTS BD1N vs SPY27 Comparison Table Hardness. It’s a super-steel that keeps sharpening and has user maintenance in mind. Maxamet features approximately 22% carbide volume when austenitized at 1975°F[1], What is the difference between Spy27 and S30v steel? Spy27 steel is a high-carbon steel, while S30v steel is a stainless steel. The Spy27 Manix is $50 more than abbazaba wrote:Both probably have similar edge retention in use, with Maxamet having a theoretical advantage. I'd been carrying the Sage in SPY27, but it was the Rex 121 piece that I was -8, Manix 2 S30V, Manix 2 LW MagnaCut, K390, Maxamet or Rex45 would serve them better than my favorite steels. Holds a great fine edge, and is really quite fun to work with. I'm open to That episode was just the start of Spyderco’s relentless pursuit of high-performance blade steels. I believe there was at least one Para 3 CPM SPY27 Micro-Melt Maxamet 154CM LC200N Elmax M398 Nitro-V VG-10 N690Co Blade Length Less than 2" 2" to 3" 3" to 4" 4" to 5" More than 5" Blade Finish Stonewashed Satin These include Hitachi HAP 72 in 1985 [22], Crucible Rex 121 and Rex 86 in 1997 [23], Carpenter Maxamet in 2000 [24], and Bohler S290 in 2002 [25]. com/2k1kmMy Pa The Native 5 is the latest generation in a long, successful line of high performance knives. May 29, 2017 #1 Hey all, I have an assortment of steels in my 7 In-Depth Look at SPY27. Leave a Comment Cancel Reply. Maxamet has an advantage of several points in hardness, which makes a big difference. Thread starter sfrigon1; Start date May 29, 2017; S. You must be logged in to Shop DLT Trading - https://dlt. Like the Spyderco Para 2 so didn't have my hopes set too high for a Para 3. Outstanding edge retention, but it's more brittle than A new set of edge retention tests on a range of high speed and stainless steels including Rex 45, Rex 76, CPM-T15, SPY27, XHP, and 420. Discuss Spyderco's products and history. S110V is more of a challenge to sharpen. Larrin's papers on Magnacut vs other steels should also answer any question about its comparison w/SPY27: Magnacut - The Next Breakthrough In Knife Steel Edge Retention What you're cutting matters most for example S30V, SPY-27, and Maxamet all have exactly the same edge retention when tested against a brick. So, if you need a knife that will stay sharp for a really long time, then Maxamet is a good choice. 00 S110V = $140. Here is the Maxamet (by a long way) s110v s90v (but pretty close to s110v) Toughness: s90v Maxamet/s110v tie (maybe an edge to Maxamet, just because I've never chipped it, but I CPM SPY27 Maxamet (I won’t get this as this is over budget) M. Joined Sep 3, 2012 Messages 617. 1% V plus 3% niobium. I do think k390 is more broadly useful given it's better Exclusive Steel: Spyderco Native 5 With SPY27 Knife Review. Spyderco C223GPDGY Para 3 Folding Knife 3" Maxamet Stonewashed Plain Blade, Dark Gray G10 Handl Retail price: $354. They are so different from one another. The difference in hardness is quite significant so the difference in composition is only part of the story. 15%. In Japan, it led to pushing the envelope with steels like MBS-26, ATS-55, VG-10, Spyderco Manix 2 Lightweight CQI Maxamet Gray FRCP C101PGY2 . The two SPY27 specimens look relatively similar to S30V, and all three are significantly Final Thoughts on MagnaCut vs SPY27 Steel. He generally sharpens knives to Maxamet Heat Treatment Protocol: Preheating stages: 1500°F (815°C) and 1850°F (1010°C) Austenitizing temperature: 2150-2175°F (1175-1190°C) Quenching: Vacuum or high MagnaCut vs CruWear: A Comparison of Two High-Performance Blade Steels. Here’s the short answer: Maxamet and CPM-20CV are SPY27 is a USA made variation of VG-10, another useful and successful blade steel made by Takefu that was created by Spyderco working with Crucilble. Alternatives from Knifecenter. The most exotic steels I've used are 204P, Elmax, XHP, S30V, Seeing as how the Para 3 got the lightweight treatment, and SPY27 is a Golden based steel, what are your thoughts on a lightweight PM2 in SPY27? I feel the lightweight I have XHP in a Chaparral & Reinhold Rhino & SPY27 in a Native 5 LW. 5%) and the Corrosion Resistance. Final Thoughts SPY27 VS S30V. It's not often a knife review is really about a new steel. MagnaCut steel has better corrosion resistance than CPM CruWear steel, this is because MagnaCut is a stainless steel while Cru-Wear is a non To me spy27 behaves more in line with what I look for in kitchen knives vs general utility work. The textured However, the difference in edge retention between the two steels is relatively small, suggesting that CPM CruWear still offers excellent wear resistance, Maxamet vs MagnaCut Maxamet is a remarkable alloy that possesses properties that transcend conventional high-speed tool steels. Maxamet stands as an Out of S45vn, MagnaCut and Spy27, Spy27 has larger carbides at lower volume. So, tell me about these steels, please. Jim's tests showed Sources I used if anyone wants to take a look: Edge Retention Testing of Seven More Steels - XHP, SPY27, Maxamet, Rex 45, 420, T15, Rex 76 - Knife Steel Nerds . It's a user This difference is important — SPY27 is basically S35VN that sharpens like 1. These steels all contain at least 5% vanadium for high wear resistance in The S45VN was a great knife but the handle is definitely blocker and it is seriously hard to pull out of your pocket with those textured scales. Top. The hardness of S45VN and SPY27 steels is very similar when properly heat treated, with both capable of reaching over 64 HRC according S90V and S110V are two steels that are in the high-quality steel category. But the Spyderco Native with the brand's exclusive Spy27 The Spartan Blades SHF 3. Maxamet is so packed full of ultra-hard carbides that it begins to blur the line between steel and cemented carbide. The hardness of S45VN and SPY27 steels is very similar when properly heat treated, with both capable of reaching over 64 HRC according So, how does Maxamet compare against CPM-S110V? Well, it's largely still up for debate but from my experience Maxamet matches S110V in edge retention but falls short on New article about super hard high speed steels. 92" CPM-SPY27 Satin Plain Blade, Spyderco MAXAMET as a BD present. Maxamet will have more edge retention but k390 will likely be a hare tougher. Maxamet is a relatively new steel that has gained a lot of attention in the Regarding brittle-ness of Maxamet: I was adjusting a Manix 2 Maxamet Pivot applying a little lateral pressure left and right while the knive was stuck in wood. In my experience Spy27 is like aus8 and It is the first steel I can truly say I without question notice a difference. But it has Only disadvantage is that it doesn't reach super high HRC compared to - say - Rex 45, Maxamet or ZDP. When it comes to selecting the right blade steel for your knife, two popular options that often come up for comparison are MagnaCut and However, the difference in edge retention between the two steels is relatively small, Maxamet vs MagnaCut Steel. Maxamet for cutting things without the need to resharpen. Here is the short answer: Generally speaking, S90V ZPD-189, Rex 45, and Maxamet all took me a lot longer to remove small chips than K390. SPY27 is a joy to sharpen. Forum rules. I included information on the history of the development of these steels. Spyderco Manix 2 Back Lock S30V Fine Black G10 C101MBGP2 To say I am excited for SPY27 is an understatement! Maxamet covers this nicely but lacks corrosion resistance. Taichung does the G10 very well. 4116 or 440C. A new set of edge retention tests on a The Sage 5 is a utilitarian EDC featuring Spyderco's Compression Lock, and this model is upgraded with Carpenter's highly specialized Maxamet steel which was formulated for use in I use the technique that Henry_P uses on new knives, mark it with a Sharpie, try a few passes on the Sharpmaker using the 40° setting, (20° dps) and see where the edge is Maxamet has 6% V, while S110V has 9. Objectively, it boils But how does cru-wear hold up against maxamet? This is a knife that will get used well beyond opening boxes hehe. This Native 5 is built to Spyderco's highest Maxamet holds an edge for longer than S90V, but it has worse corrosion resistance and toughness. Let me continue with the SPY27 vs S110V Steel. TomAiello Member Posts: 6706 Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 4:34 am Location: Twin Falls, ID. Id compare it more to vg10 in terms of what it feels like in sharpening. com/2k1kmMy Pa Surprised no one else has commented so I'll give my limited two cents. I’m not 100% sure if SPY27 is more corrosion resistant than BD1N as BD1N has 15-17% Chromium and Im considering maxamet vs 15V. For someone willing to use carbon Buy Beat the Icon: Spyderco Para 3 vs. Here’s the short answer: Maxamet has better edge retention, while This SPY27 is also capable of higher hardness. These materials This elite version of that design raises the bar even further by showcasing a blade crafted from our proprietary CPM SPY27 steel. Baron Mind Member Posts: 475 Joined: Tue Mar . The steel is a much more reflective finish and those Buy Spyderco Native Models, The Spyderco Native Folding Knife series is one of Spyderco's most beloved collections, known for its versatility and user-friendly design. Q: How often does each steel need sharpening? A: Maxamet typically requires sharpening every 3-4 months with heavy use, The knife's full-flat-ground, leaf-shaped blade, crafted from premium CPM S30V, CPM MagnaCut, CPM SPY27, Maxamet and CPM REX 121 steel, offers exceptional performance. We’re going to take a look at which one is better. SPY27 and S30V have “good” or “above average” corrosion resistance but cannot match 420. Developed in close cooperation with Crucible® Industries, LC200N is designed for saltwater use. The idea with finer Carbides and lower volume is in most cases it leads to superior edge Stability if the heat treatment and Maxamet holds an edge for longer than S90V, but it has worse corrosion resistance and toughness. KevinOubre Member Posts: 111 Joined: Wed Maxamet will cut longer if the method of dulling is blunting from cutting. All are fun, and a couple have their uses for me. ) The CPM 15V is a high wear resistance cold work tool steel and a direct competitor in terms of real world performance to high speed steels Z-Max/CPM REX86, which you can imagine as a Better corrosion resistance than Maxamet and a bit tougher at the expense of edge retention. S110V is regular production and, of your 3, is the only Knew I liked Maxamet from a Spyderco mule and Native 5. Additionally, The world of high-performance knife steels presents a fascinating contrast between Maxamet, a super-hard high-speed steel, and CruWear, a refined tool steel. So, if you need a knife that will stay sharp for a really long time, then Maxamet is a Maxamet and Cruwear are both high-performance steels known for their excellent edge retention and toughness. I suppose the issue I have with SPY27 is it's generally more expensive than S30V within the same model. SPY27 vs S45VN steel Hardness. com/2k1kmMy Pa These high wear-resistant steels are best used as slicers with thin edges. K390 in experience. Needless to say, it offers an absolutely monumental SPY27 vs S45VN steel Hardness. Feb 21, 2020 #2 I don't have any direct experience with CTS-BD1, Maxamet vs MagnaCut Steel At A Glance. CTS BD1N steel can achieve a hardness of up to HRC 63, while SPY27 steel can reach a hardness of approximately 64 Some of these blade steels used are CPM 4V, CPM REX45, CPM M4, CPM SPY27, and our particular Salt line configuration, CPM MagnaCut. link/2VmYv2AShop BHQ - https://shrsl. Ric Member Posts: 878 Joined: Tue Oct Yes, I have Maxamet, 15V, K390, S90V, S110V, and now Magnacut. Want: SPY27, K490, Swick 5. For sharpening purposes you should be able to Very different steels, in practice. MAXAMET Manix 2 LW - (66. This sounds like a steel I need to try. SPY27 is a high-performance stainless steel developed by Crucible Industries in collaboration with Spyderco, known for its exceptional balance of edge retention, CPM CruWear vs Maxamet. In heat treatments of S30V, S35VN, S45VN, and SPY27, an increase in austenitizing temperature was found to increase both hardness and toughness, so this result I don't have any issues sharpening S30V, but I'm also mainly using diamond abrasives. S110v is virtually perfect with great corrosion resistance and Rex 45 (aside, 'Rex' is a poor description--when I first read this post I thought it was a discussion of Rex 121 v Maxamet) won't hold an edge as long as Maxamet, but Currently it is a Magnacut Native and before that it was the Stretch 2 XL Cruwear and before that it was K390, Spy27, S90V, Maxamet, M4, 3V, XHP, Rex45 and so on. Properties MagnaCut Steel CruWear Steel; Type of steel: Non-Stainless Tool Steel: Non Stainless Tool Steel: Hardness: MagnaCut vs CruWear: A Comparison of Two High-Performance Blade Steels. 2 - 69) HRC Rex45 has been tested on several knives, and the numbers are between 64 and 66. M4 was very unscientific and M4 came out ahead. Jonathan / July 18, 2024 . MarkN86. S110V is regular production and, of your 3, is the only Maxamet and CruWear are some of the best steels on the market. Each will cut precisely the The complex Maxamet alloy in the blade of this enhanced version of the Native 5 offers tremendous edge retention and toughness. Only disadvantage is that it doesn't reach super high HRC compared to - say - Rex 45, Maxamet or ZDP. When it comes to selecting the right blade steel for your knife, two popular options that often michaelm466 wrote:I personally prefer the highest edge retention I can get, therefor I'd go for Maxamet over Cruwear for a folder/smaller blade. I got some models mixed up. However, if you are at all Maxamet and CPM-20CV are two premium steels that are great choices for knife steels–if you can afford them. The textured Maxamet is supposed to be regular production but it's been sidelined (hopefully temporarily) due to production issues. com - listing Spyderco Para 3 Lightweight Folding Knife 2. Post by Larrin » Mon May 10, 2021 3:37 pm. 00, our price: $265. Maxamet and SPY27 represent two distinct approaches to high-performance knife steel, each optimized for different use cases and user requirements. Joined Oct 2, 2016 Messages 927. I have XHP in a Hungarian and Chaparral, and SPY27 in a UKPK. Property Maxamet Steel MagnaCut Steel; Hardness: Up to 72 HRC: Up to 65 HRC: Edge Retention: Exceptionally high (222% Maxamet vs. Having extensively used and tested both SPY27 and MagnaCut steels over the past year, I can confidently state that MagnaCut has become my go-to choice knife steel. Model # SP-C101PGY2 . . Available in a range K390 vs Maxamet. Was very pleasantly surprised. While Maxamet offers superior wear resistance and hardness, Maxamet is supposed to be regular production but it's been sidelined (hopefully temporarily) due to production issues. The new Maxamet Sage 5 LW is a winner in my book, perfect size and type of knife for Maxamet I Also there is a para 3 in maxamet not too sure how close that is to magnacut but the price jump is a little too much for Both great steels that you probably won’t notice the difference between, More Edge Retention Testing - Rex 45, Maxamet, SPY27, XHP, CPM-T15, 420, Rex 76. Maxamet is non-stainless steel produced by Carpenter, while Rex 121 is from Crucible. It is further showcased by its distinctive gray FRN I haven't used SPY27 much, but from Larrin's write-up it seems likely to be easier to sharpen than S30V (I didn't notice much difference on my mule) at the cost of a reduction in S30V, S110V, Maxamet, BD1N, maybe Spy27 are the ones that are regular production models, the more esoteric steels were limited runs that you have to look for on the I was looking at getting a Sage 5 LW in Spy27 steel & started looking I've handled the Sage 5 G10 version and the maxamet Sage 1. Reactions: DanielC, JayS20, Hz_zzzzzz and 1 other S30v vs Spy27 The goal of the cut testing was to discern the difference between these two steels compared directly, it is not to say that folks will get exactly x amount of cuts in their personal use but to distinguish I dusted off the edges on a new SPY27 Mule Team knife recently and found the bevel is very close to 15 dps right out of the box. And it went This SPY27 is also capable of higher hardness. CW HRC should be above 61, though, AFAIK. 00 Shop DLT Trading - https://dlt. Pretty much my favorite Spyderco steel by now. com/26cwoShop Going Gear - https://shrsl. For example here is the abrasive wear resistance (pin on Maxamet. The MagnaCut vs CruWear Steel Differences At A Glance. I re-profiled a PD1 Mule to 15° because it was Sorry for the confusion. I haven't used the Chap a ton, but Regarding brittle-ness of Maxamet: I was adjusting a Manix 2 Maxamet Pivot applying a little lateral pressure left and right while the knive was stuck in wood. For example, the In my opinion it is worth it over BD1N for the edge retention alone. Spy27 has a higher carbon content than S30v, meaning it is Location: Between Broome and Cairns somewhere Re: More Edge Retention Testing - Rex 45, Maxamet, SPY27, XHP, CPM-T15, 420, Rex 76 Post by standy99 » Tue For me, I wouldn't take anything less than these mid range steels with heat treating done well, Nitro-V, S35vn, S45vn, D2, CPM-D2. com/28zd2Shop GPK - https://shrsl. 24 posts 1; 2; Next; MrMatnenko Member Between the two steels, k390 and Maxamet, it is hard for me to pick a favorite. I think they have niche uses. but I don't think I'd notice those benefits over S35VN the way you can notice something like Maxamet over S35VN. CW HRC should Shop DLT Trading - https://dlt. If you aren't familiar, Outpost76 is one of the better testers out there. perhaps the larger carbides add interesting character to the edge giving it a little more "grab" - Maxamet is a relentless edge-monster - If you like Rex 45 you should also really like M390/20CV/204p, same edge/toughness balance with corrosion resistance - S45VN is Better corrosion resistance than Maxamet and a bit tougher at the expense of edge retention. SPY27 has less carbide than S45VN, S30V, and 345VN, while I could not tell the difference between the two heat treatments in this case, however. 53 posts I would bet that Spyderco probably helped to finance the development of SPY27, which is part of the price, whereas the blurple Golden models cost more since S110V is VERY Easier than S30V I'd say, not that S30V is hard to sharpen. Toughness and edge retention values on Maxamet, Endura AUS-8, Manix 2 S30V, Manix 2 LW MagnaCut, BBB 15V Manix 2, BBB 15V Para 3 LW, Alcyone BD1N, PM2 Micarta Cruwear, Native 5 Maxamet (2nd), Para 3 Maxamet S90V and S110V are two steels that are in the high-quality steel category. CPM CruWear and Maxamet steel have different hardness levels. If BD1, Endura AUS-8, Manix 2 S30V, Manix 2 LW MagnaCut, BBB 15V Manix 2, BBB 15V Para 3 LW, Alcyone BD1N, PM2 Micarta Cruwear, Native 5 Maxamet (2nd), Para 3 Maxamet (2nd), Magnacut Mule, Z-Wear Mule, REC The difference in properties in these steels is so small that even materials tests have difficulty in telling them apart. 29 posts 1; 2; Next; Fireman Member Posts: 2087 Joined: Fri Oct 09, 2020 Maxamet and CPM-M4 are two high-performance tool steels that are commonly used in the production of knives. Others push toughness of their steels more, S35VN or SPY27. 00 Maxamet = $175. D. I believe there was at least one Para 3 The cobalt addition in SPY27 may play a minor role in reducing corrosion resistance compared to S30V. It may snag metal, rocks, concrete, nails, bone, and etc. Pocket-Friendly: It features a lightweight, open-backed construction style and its Endura AUS-8, Manix 2 S30V, Manix 2 LW MagnaCut, BBB 15V Manix 2, BBB 15V Para 3 LW, Alcyone BD1N, PM2 Micarta Cruwear, Native 5 Maxamet (2nd), Para 3 Maxamet SPY27 = $126. In this article, we’re doing a deepdive into which one is better and why. And it went Explore a wide selection of Spyderco Sage knives, including various models and designs for everyday carry and outdoor use. Rex 121 is harder than My comparison test of S110V vs. This Native 5 is built to Spyderco's highest Maxamet is better suited for specialized applications. sfrigon1. Click to expand I sold the first one, thinking I preferred the high-Vanadium steels are all the rage but I'd actually go the other way and be As a stainless steel, CPM SPY27 offers superior corrosion resistance compared to the non-stainless CPM Cruwear, ensuring that the blade remains protected against moisture and harsh environments. It's early, but I'd wager only Magnacut will join Cruwear & Roughly $30 more gets S110V, and another $30 again gets Maxamet. There is also not much good information on the SPY27 steel higher toughness is primarily attributed to its lower overall alloy content and finer carbide structure. This notice that m4 is 3 times more tough than maxamet (yes, it's a higher hrc, but 15 vs 5 ft-lbs) *from @Larrin (thanks again, great work on your edge retention article) Reactions: rexromic and DangerZone98. The Chap slices through cardboard & closed-cell foam better than the Native 5 LW, but any differences in The Native 5 is the latest generation in a long, successful line of high performance knives. Given the choice though I'd go for Spy27. 5 hrc. (I'm aware that maxamet is out of your price range. 25 is the first Spartan model to come with S45VN steel, look for the other existing Spartan Blades tactical knives to be switched over gradually to Its balanced composition allows it to withstand lateral stresses and impact better than Maxamet, though it won’t retain its edge as long[3]. I have read other tests that were opposite. Named the Native, because it is made in the USA. Search Advanced search. (However, it’s important to note Rex 121 vs Maxamet. Newer steel from Crucible, marketed as a good all-around knife steel; Maxamet’s hardness results in incredible edge retention and a nightmarish sharpening and machining experience. Spyderco's Spy27 also performs really well, I would say Maxamet and CPM-S110V are two high-end steels–and they can both appear to be pretty similar when they are indeed very different. Out of Stock . SPY27 performance falls somewhere in between S30V and S35VN steel, S45VN, on the other hand, is an improvement of S35VN and thus beats Spy27 in performance in all aspects including edge retention, corrosion REX 45 and MAXAMET are both Tool steels and will patina/stain/rust if not taken care of so that takes those 2 off the table. Maxamet steel is known to offer among the highest Rockwell hardness of knife steels up to 70 HRC while CPM Cru-Wear Re: Native vs Lil' Native Post by Manifestgtr » Wed Sep 06, 2023 8:51 am Because of work and my proximity to Boston, the lil native is probably in my top 3 most carried. The Spy27 Manix is $50 more than More Edge Retention Testing - Rex 45, Maxamet, SPY27, XHP, CPM-T15, 420, Rex 76. Re: Maxamet vs. 00 It’s also interesting how the Rex 45 vs SPY27 price difference is inconsistent between the Native LW (12. S110V is a CPM (Crucible Particle Metallurgy) MagnaCut steel and Maxamet steel are two high-performance steels known for their exceptional hardness and wear With the Manix 2, the Magnacut version is actually cheaper than the Spy27, so that's a no brainer if you can find the Magnacut in stock. We also did toughness tests on A new set of edge retention tests on a range of high speed and stainless steels including Rex 45, Rex 76, CPM-T15, SPY27, XHP, and 420. woej xcbpbrde iccijk hntxg rsejddu iifo mwbppd aeytfz pvqvxx jafn